Them Jewelers Gift Guide 2026: Holiday Lockets, Name Hoops and Chains That Arrive on Time
It's the first week of December. The list is stuck to the fridge: your sister, your best friend, your mom, the coworker who covered for you in August, and a boyfriend who claims he "doesn't wear jewelry." Five names, five budgets, and a calendar that suddenly looks very short.
Them Jewelers, the New York shop that signs its pages The M Jewelers, can cover most of that list, from a $31 pair of tiny huggies to a hand-engraved heart in 14KT gold. But this is a made-to-order jeweler, and timing matters as much as taste. Olivia Reviews went through the brand's Holiday Edit, gift price collections, product listings and policies in October 2026 to build a holiday 2026 gift plan that actually arrives on time.
Quick take: Ready-made pieces like huggies, hand chains and earring sets ship within 1–2 business days, so they're the safe late-December choices. Engraved and name pieces are made by hand and the brand quotes anywhere from 8–14 business days to several weeks, so order those first. Personalized gifts are final sale, and the brand extends its return window to 30 days for non-personalized items during the holiday season. See today's Them Jewelers deals before you start adding to the bag.
Shop by the Calendar, Not Just the Budget
Most gift guides start with price. With Them Jewelers, start with lead time. The brand's own pages describe three speeds:
- In-stock pieces: processed and shipped within 1–2 business days.
- Engraved pieces: the Engraved Puff Heart Locket and Hand Engraved Heart Pendant list an estimated 8–14 business days in production, and 14KT engraved items can take up to 20 business days.
- Personalized name pieces: the shipping policy now quotes 2–5 weeks to produce and ship, while the FAQ mentions around 14 days for personalized and 14KT made-to-order items.
The FAQ also warns that handmade orders placed around the holidays can be delayed by the volume of orders, and that expedited shipping speeds up delivery only after a piece is made. The brand doesn't publish a specific holiday order cutoff, so the safest plan is simple: custom gifts in late October or November, ready-made gifts in December.
Gifts Under $50: Small Boxes, Big Reactions
The Mini Pavé Huggie Earrings ($31.20) are roughly a quarter inch across, set with cubic zirconia in 18KT gold-plated brass. They're the kind of earring that stays in all week, which makes them an easy yes for a friend whose taste you're unsure of. The Heart Rosary ($44.20) from the Holiday Edit is an 18" chain with a 2" heart drop in 18KT gold filled, a sentimental pick for someone who wears her faith close.
Gifts From $50 to $100: The Sweet Spot
The Engraved Puff Heart Locket — $74
A plump heart locket in brass with 18KT gold or rhodium plating, hanging from a 16" cable chain. It sits in the brand's Best Sellers and Holiday Edit, and it has the feel of something passed down, without the price. Each one is made to order with an estimated 8–14 business days of production, so this is an early-shopping gift.
Give it to: mom, a grandmother, or anyone who keeps photos in their wallet.
The Hand Engraved Heart Pendant Necklace — $98
Here a jeweler engraves the name, word or phrase onto a heart pendant by hand, which is why the listing warns that the preview render won't match exactly. It comes on a 16" cable chain in gold vermeil or silver at $98, or 14KT yellow or white gold at $860. The vermeil version estimates 8–14 business days; the 14KT version can take up to 20 business days.
Give it to: a partner, with a date or nickname only the two of you understand. Type it exactly as you want it, since the brand produces personalizations as entered.
The Pavé Hand Chain — $58
For the friend who dresses up for every party, this one turns a bare hand into the accessory. A 6" bracelet with a 1" extender links to a 2.6" strand of 18 cubic zirconia stones that runs down to the finger, in 14KT gold-plated brass. It comes in clear or emerald stones. As a ready-made piece, it's one to keep in your back pocket for mid-December.
Give it to: the New Year's Eve planner in your group.
→ Check the latest Them Jewelers coupon codes and deals
Earring sets for the person who has everything
Three ready-made sets solve the "one gift, several looks" problem. The Dainty Earring Set ($68) includes earrings in 0.5", 0.75" and 0.90" sizes in 18KT gold-plated brass with cubic zirconia. The Textured Huggie Set ($68) pairs 0.5", 0.5" and 1" sizes. And The M Essential Earring Set ($98) groups earrings that each measure 0.5" top to bottom. A set is a smart wrap-and-go present for anyone with multiple piercings.
Personalized Gifts From $100 to $200
The Bamboo Name Hoops — $117
Big, joyful and unmistakably New York. These bamboo-style hoops are 2 inches in diameter, with a name in script across the middle, in 18KT gold plating or rhodium plating. They're tagged as a Best Seller, crafted by hand on order, final sale and backed by a 120-day warranty.
Give it to: the sister who has never once worn small earrings.
The Bubble Nameplate Necklace — $145
A softer, more playful take on the nameplate. The letters are 6mm tall and 1.5–1.7mm thick, with a maximum width of 1.15"–1.25", and the listing takes names of 6 to 10 letters on a 16" cable chain. It comes in gold vermeil or sterling silver. If her name is shorter than six letters, look at other nameplate styles instead.
For a two-tone look, the Classic Double Heart Nameplate Necklace ($168) sets a name in two-tone 18kt gold vermeil on an 18" Figaro chain.
For Him: Chains That Don't Need Convincing
The "I don't wear jewelry" boyfriend usually changes his mind with a chain that looks good over a black tee. The Figaro Chain (Men's) is 5.8mm thick in 14KT gold-plated or rhodium-plated brass, $168 for 20" or $178 for 22", and it arrived with the brand's new men's chains in October 2026. A matching Figaro Link Bracelet (Men's) runs $78–$88. For something personal, the Small Varsity Number Pendant Necklace lets him wear a jersey number, from $64 in plated brass, $94 in vermeil or sterling, and $580 in 14KT gold.
For the Whole Group: Bundles
Buying for a friend group or a bridal party? The Tiny Script Nameplate Bracelet Bundle 4 Pack was listed at $217.60, down from $256. That's four personalized bracelets for matching gifts. Just remember that every piece is personalized, which makes the whole bundle final sale.
Holiday Gift Comparison
| Gift | Price (USD) | Good for | Speed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mini Pavé Huggie Earrings | $31.20 | Stocking stuffer | Ready-made |
| Heart Rosary | $44.20 | A sentimental keepsake | Ready-made |
| Pavé Hand Chain | $58 | Party season | Ready-made |
| Dainty or Textured Huggie Set | $68 | Multiple piercings | Ready-made |
| Engraved Puff Heart Locket | $74 | Mom or grandma | 8–14 business days |
| Hand Engraved Heart Pendant | $98 / $860 (14KT) | A partner | 8–14 days; 14KT up to 20 |
| Bamboo Name Hoops | $117 | Bold dressers | Made to order |
| Bubble Nameplate Necklace | $145 | A playful name piece | Made to order |
| Figaro Chain (Men's) | $168–$178 | Him | Ready-made |
| Gift card | $10–$1,000 | Last-minute or picky recipients | Delivered by email |
What to Know Before You Wrap
Shipping: The site banner advertises free domestic shipping on orders of $95 or more, while the shipping policy lists free UPS First Class Mail on orders over $100, $5 below that, and USPS Priority (1–3 business days) for $12. Once shipped, domestic orders typically take 1–3 business days. If an order mixes in-stock and personalized pieces, the brand says the personalized items ship separately at no extra charge.
Returns: Non-personalized, full-price items can be returned within 14 days of delivery, extended to 30 days during the holiday season, minus a 10% restocking fee unless the item arrived damaged or defective. Personalized items, sale items and orders placed with promo codes are final sale; promo-code orders qualify for store credit only.
Cancellations: The policy page allows cancellations within 1 hour, the FAQ says 30 minutes, and the FAQ lists Black Friday, Cyber Monday and Christmas sale orders as final. Double-check names, letters and lengths before you pay.
Warranty: Listings such as the Bamboo Name Hoops and Bubble Nameplate mention a 120-day warranty.
The Upside and the Catch
What we like
- Gift ideas at nearly every price, from $31.20 huggies to 14KT engraved pendants.
- Plenty of ready-made pieces for December shoppers.
- A longer 30-day return window for non-personalized items in the holiday season.
- Email-delivered gift cards from $10 to $1,000 that don't expire.
- A men's chain range that makes shopping for him easier.
What to watch
- Personalized and engraved gifts can't be returned or exchanged.
- Production estimates differ between pages, and the brand flags holiday delays.
- No published holiday shipping cutoff.
- Peak-season orders can't be cancelled.
Who This Gift Guide Suits
A good match if you like giving jewelry with a name, a date or a meaning attached, and you can shop a few weeks ahead. It's also handy for mixed lists, since one order can cover a sister, a friend and a partner.
Skip the custom pieces if you're shopping in the last week before the holiday or you're not sure of the exact spelling. In that case, stick to ready-made styles or a gift card.
Ways to Spend Less on Holiday Gifts
- Combine gifts in one order to clear $100 and avoid shipping fees, for example a Hand Engraved Heart Pendant ($98) plus Mini Pavé Huggies ($31.20).
- Use bundles for groups: the Tiny Script Nameplate Bracelet Bundle 4 Pack saves $38.40 against its listed price.
- Consider The M Club if you're buying several gifts: the brand describes $19 a month converted into $19 of store credit, an extra 15% off orders and a free first month, with the option to pause or cancel.
- Check for a current offer first. We didn't see a public code on the site, so browse current Them Jewelers coupons and keep the store-credit rule for promo-code orders in mind.
Holiday Gifting FAQ
What's a good Them Jewelers gift if I'm ordering late?
Choose ready-made pieces such as the Mini Pavé Huggies, Pavé Hand Chain, earring sets or men's chains, which ship within 1–2 business days, or send a gift card, which the brand delivers by email.
Can someone return a gift with their name on it?
No. Personalized items are final sale. Non-personalized, full-price gifts can be returned within the holiday window of 30 days, minus a 10% restocking fee.
Does Them Jewelers have a holiday shipping deadline?
We didn't find a published cutoff in October 2026. The brand notes that holiday order volume can cause delays, so order custom gifts several weeks early.
What gift card amounts are available?
The M Jewelers gift card was listed from $10 up to $1,000, including $25, $50, $100, $200 and $500 options. According to the listing, gift cards are delivered by email, can be used online and in-store, and don't expire.
Final Verdict
Them Jewelers makes holiday shopping feel personal: a locket for mom, name hoops for your sister, a Figaro chain for the man who swore he'd never wear one. The key is sequencing. Order engraved and name pieces early, fill the gaps with ready-made huggies, hand chains and earring sets in December, and fall back on a gift card if time runs out. Before you check out, see the newest Them Jewelers savings.
→ Check the latest Them Jewelers coupon codes and deals
Olivia Reviews researched Them Jewelers using its official website, product listings and published policies in October 2026. We haven't personally tested these products. We may earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you.